1. Skip to navigation
  2. Skip to content
  3. Skip to sidebar



What IS cashing in?

Apr 23, 2015 04:07 pm

It has been with great interest that I watch the rising debate on ‘cashing in’ on the Anzac theme this year. This is clearly a subject that gets people fired up and understandably so. Like many, I’ve been disappointed with the major corporations who have attempted to pull at the heartstrings of a caring nation seemingly in order to make money. I’ve seen Anzac bears, Gallipoli mugs, clothing, and at Target, I was even confronted by a scented Gallipoli candle. I don’t like to judge before knowing all the facts, so I did some research… Target, partnered with Camp Gallipoli (who have since removed the items from sale), claim that all surplus profits from the sale of ‘Camp Gallipoli’ merchandise would be donated to the RSL and Legacy. This I didn’t know, it eased my spikes on the matter a little. Still, we’re all pretty uncomfortable (and quite grumpy at Woolies, who had no such charity connections and didn’t even obtain the word ‘Anzac’ legally).
Every Australian has an emotional connection to the word Anzac, we want to remember our fallen with pride and let nothing disrespect or betray the Anzac legacy. An interesting read is ‘Poppies For Profit’ which has the sickening line:
80,000 Anzac troops died in the first world war. Surely we can make a few bucks out of that?
I can’t tell you how uncomfortable that makes me feel. And so does the long list of profiting companies on this site. It makes me want to reach for something to help me to honour the Anzacs. I can’t wear the commemorative Anzac footy t-shirt someone gave me, I can’t cool my drink with this Gallipoli stubby holder I was sent – it’s just not right, someone has made money from this.
And then a CD arrives in the mail. It’s Lee Kernaghan’s ‘Spirit Of The Anzacs,’ and I must say, I’m curious. I recently read posts on social media from people (and sadly many are fellow industry members) accusing Lee of the same ‘cashing in’ as the aforementioned companies. So I listen to the album.
I am in tears.
Lee and his cowriters have nailed it, simple as that. I wonder if his accusers have heard these songs? Lee hasn’t stuck a slouch hat on a teddy bear here; he has studied stories of Australians in all the wars, and retold them in these songs. He has sat down with people and listened to their stories, the stories of beloved family members and presented them back to them as music. Clearly, this is a project driven by heart and empathy, not profit… you can’t write these kind of songs with dollar signs in your eyes and those accusing him of it should take a listen… it’s brilliant!
And there is a close association and generous contributions to both Legacy and Soldier On which pleases me greatly.
This is what we DO as songwriters, as storytellers – there will be people listening to these songs getting their very first education into what this country has gone through, what these servicemen and women have sacrificed and what they have fought for. And you want to drag the guy down for that?
Most of these stories would have gone untold if it weren’t for Lee, as a very patriotic Australian, I am grateful.
My first education on the subject was through listening to Eric Bogle’s ‘And The Band Played Waltzing Matilda’ as a kid and later, John Williamson’s ‘The Diggers Of The Anzac’ (I think I was about 20) and of course John Schumann’s ‘I Was Only 19,’ incredible songs.
You can’t underestimate the power of these songs – no one dared to accuse John, Eric and JW of ‘cashing in’ so why attack Lee? He’s not bloody Woolworths!

Maybe there’s something in this:
Tall poppy syndrome: a social phenomenon in which people of genuine merit are resented, attacked, cut down, or criticised because their talents or achievements elevate them above or distinguish them from their peers.

Before you go accusing me of ‘sticking up for a mate’ – I need to add that I don’t know Lee well at all. We say g’day, kiss on the cheek and I’ve been on the same show as him a bunch of times, his wife Robby has always been kind and lovely to me but there’s no bond that drives me to defend him! I also can’t say there’s too much LK shuffling around my ipod, I admire him for sure but I can’t say I’ve been moved emotionally by him until now.

I haven’t written any specific Anzac or ‘war’ songs but many would know that I have great affection for our service women and men and have written a couple of more personal songs about my associations with specific diggers (I’m not even going to mention their names, I’m not about to plug myself in this blog!) – my heart would simply break if I was accused of writing those songs for a profit, especially by my peers.

We don’t accuse the moviemakers, who tell the stories of Gallipoli and beyond, of profiting from the war. I saw The Water Diviner the other day and wept uncontrollably (on the plane). The film made me ache for the Australians killed and for the families they left behind. We all need to find a way to ache for them.

This Saturday is Anzac day and my day will look like this: I will attend the dawn service and I will weep for our fallen. I won’t sing, I’ve told them I can’t, there will be no notes in my voice (I’m too much of a sook). I will watch the march, rain, hail or shine (weeping, of course). I will lose it completely when those marching give an ‘eyes right’ to the Legacy war widows. I will shake the hands of as many servicemen and women as I can and I will thank them. I will raise a glass of morning beer to my great grandfather, my godfather and my uncle and then I’ll go home and crank JW, John Schumann, Eric Bogle AND Lee’s album as loud as it will go and I WILL REMEMBER THEM.

4 Comments

  1. This is something that you feel very passionate about Beccy as I do, along with many other Australians. My grandfather, Private Benjamin James Pedder fought on the Western Front during WW1 and was one of the fortunate ones who returned home, serving in the armed forces from 1914 – 1920. He was badly wounded, and for the few years I knew him as a child, I remember distinctly the metal rods he was required to wear so he was able to walk. I know he saw many unspeakable things as a young man. He was 21 when he went away to the war. His valour and courage are carried with me and although like many men who returned home, he could not speak of his story, he preferred to speak of the lost brave souls he fought with. He was proud of his country. And of the values upon which he was raised. There are many men and women for that matter, whose stories and voices need to be heard. Music is something which can unify and bring people together, this is what artists like yourself and Lee and JW have done. You’ve gone voice to my grandfather and what he stood for. You’ve kept their spirit alive and I thank you for that. It means something, and I am upset to think anyone would question Lee’s or your motives in any way but good. When I first became a school principal I was once asked by some of my students why ANZAC day was so important to me and why I made a big deal out of it at school. In a world where some are blinded by hatred and respond with violence or abuse it is important for us all, not just young people, to remember that in The Great War and others after, these soldiers fought for the freedom we enjoy and our way of life. Every time I hear Redgum’s I Was Only 19 is a very emotional time for me. Storytelling is something Australians do very well. Music is such a wonderful communicator and you and others like you write with such truth and honesty.But it’s more than that it’s passionately told because it’s from the heart and because it means something to you. So thank you Beccy for the responsibility you tell your stories with about this subject and support of our troops. You and Angry are legends. I too will be having a beer for my grandfather and think of every digger who has played a role in my ability to enjoy this awesome country we live in. Woolies did the wrong thing, commercial profit has no place in the Anzac tradition. It’s abhorrent and disrespectful. I think that’s the word! The quality of a person is in the humanity they show for others and their capacity to love. You have a big heart Beccy Cole!

  2. Well I am the granddaughter of wwII vetran and daughter of Vietnam vetran and I don’t think any songs are cashing in on Anzac I think that is ridiculous. I think it is awesome that people like yourself and Lee take the time to pay tribute to our diggers past and present and helps people be remembered and makes people remember so I say thank you thank you very much Lest we forget

  3. You go Beccy let them have it,completely agree with every thing you had to say if people think you are sticking up for a mate,to bad they did not read your blog properly. Sorry I am still trying to get through your book,one minute I am laughing next I am crying my eyes out .glad you are so happy now.

  4. Could not agree with you more Beccy – sometimes people just need to stop and think before they start making comparisons when apples just ain’t oranges. Anzac Day is a time for us to remember those who we lost – in many cases names and faces of men we never got to know, but who at least once a year we think of and shake our heads and wonder why? It’s a time to also give thanks to those who are now serving in the armed forces. Perhaps peoples efforts could be better spent recognising our Broken Soldiers and putting pen to paper or contacting shock jocks or pollies to make sure we take care of our men and women when they leave the forces and not attack a story teller who has made sure that memories are not lost. Again well said Beccy.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>